Pineapple pie is a family favorite around here. It has always been my mother’s favorite, and growing up we all loved it. When I met my husband I was surprised to find it was one of his favorites, as well (along with blueberry and cherry). Although my mother baked frequently, for this particular type of pie, we usually had Table Talk, store bought pies. None of the better bakeries made this pie. Although eating a Table Talk pie, brings back childhood memories, it leaves something to be desired. A few years back I decided to make my own recipe. I’ve never had a mass produced pineapple pie again. I usually make individual double crust mini-pies, which I bake in tart pans (shallow muffin tins could also work).
Pineapple Pie Recipe
Pineapple Pie Filling:
20 oz. can of crushed pineapple w/ juice
3/4 c. sugar
1 tsp. lemon juice
1 tsp. vanilla extract
3 tbs. cornstarch
- Mix all ingredients in saucepan
- Over med/high heat, keep stirring while you bring filling to a boil.
- After about a minute of boiling the filling should be thick enough.
- Take it off burner and set aside.
Pie Crust (see my Ultimate Pie Crust Recipe)
- Half of rolled out crust should be gently placed in pie plate. It is better to nestle the dough then shape it, than to pull the dough down to the shape of the plate. (if making individual pies cut the bottom crust about figuring about an extra inch on all sides, larger than the size of each tin)
- Fill close to the top, but leave a little space so filling won’t bubble over.
- Dampen edge of crust with a damp cloth (so top crust will stick better.
- Place top crust on and press edges down .
- Trim off excess dough , and crimp edges.
- Cut a small slit in the top crust, to allow steam to escape.
- Bake at 425 degrees for approx. 30 minutes (mini pies will only take about half that time.
- Serve once cooled.